π Factory Method vs Abstract Factory
β
Purpose of Comparisonβ
Both Factory Method and Abstract Factory are creational patterns used to encapsulate object creation. However, they differ in scale, responsibility, and intended use. This page compares their structure and use cases to clarify which pattern suits a given scenario.
β
Comparison Overviewβ
Aspect | Factory Method | Abstract Factory |
---|
Focus | Creation of a single object | Creation of a family of related objects |
Structure | Abstract method in base class creates product | A factory interface creates multiple product types |
Extensibility | Easy to add new product types | Good for managing multiple object types across families |
Coupling | Low (based on a product interface) | Higher complexity but clearer coordination across product sets |
Typical Use | When subclass decides what to instantiate | When consistent object families are required |
β
Similaritiesβ
- Both abstract the instantiation process to reduce dependency on concrete classes.
- Both improve extensibility by centralizing creation logic.
- Both adhere to the Open/Closed Principle, allowing extensions without modification.
β
Key Differencesβ
Aspect | Factory Method | Abstract Factory |
---|
Product Scope | Single product | Multiple related products (families) |
Client Interaction | Subclass decides what to return | Factory provides families via interface |
Usage Complexity | Simpler | More structured but heavier setup |
Flexibility | Easy to plug different product implementations | Maintains consistency across related components |
β
UML Class Diagramsβ
Factory Method Patternβ
Abstract Factory Patternβ
β
Practical Design Notesβ
- β
Use Factory Method when you need a flexible way to create one type of object at a time (e.g., single plugin or handler).
- β
Use Abstract Factory when object consistency matters, like building a UI theme or cross-platform toolkit.
- π Factory Method can be part of Abstract Factoryβs internal structure to create individual items.
β
Summaryβ
Factory Method
encapsulates how to create a single object.
Abstract Factory
provides a group of related object creators.
- Abstract Factory is ideal when multiple coordinated products must be consistent.
- Choose based on the scope of creation: if you need consistency across multiple products, go with Abstract Factory; otherwise, Factory Method may be sufficient.