Summary
Pattern Comparison
Pattern | When to Apply | Strengths | Caveats | Common Use Cases |
---|---|---|---|---|
Factory Method | When choosing implementations dynamically | Great extensibility | Requires subclass-based design | Flexible creation of simple objects |
Abstract Factory | When generating related objects as a group | Enables consistent environment setup | Slightly more complex structure | UI configuration, environment switching |
Builder | When building objects in multiple steps | Flexible and clear construction | Overkill for simple objects | Multi-stage initialization scenarios |
Singleton | When sharing a single instance globally | Shared state, high reusability | Can hinder testing and dependency injection | Logger, configuration, cache |
Choosing the Right Pattern
- Frequent use of
new
scattered across the code is a sign of design issues - Centralizing instantiation improves testability, extensibility, and maintainability
- Choose the pattern based on object complexity and relationships among instances
Team Discussion Snippets
- “There’s too much
new
scattered around—let’s manage this with aFactory
.” - “Since the logger is shared, we might want to make it a
Singleton
.” - “This object has a complex set of properties—
Builder
could make it clearer.” - “If we need to switch dependencies per environment,
Abstract Factory
might fit.”